The Devil in The Details: Why Making Home Affordable Isn't Working The Way It Should
Posted in Buying a House, Credit on 05/18/2009 09:03 pm by DDLIt’s been over two months since the government released guidelines for the Making Home Affordable program (formerly known as the Homeowner Affordability and Stability Program), which was designed to allow homeowners to refinance their mortgages into more stable, equity-building 30 year fixed rate plans. The goal of the Making Home Affordable program is to enable homeowners whose home values are now worth less than their mortgages a chance to take advantage of historically low interest rates - an opportunity that would otherwise be lost due to their lack of equity.
It’s a great idea, but the execution of the Making Home Affordable program has, so far, been wrought with confusion and outright failure. A quick search on the internet reveals that the number of people being refinanced under this plan is far surpassed by the number of people being turned away. The rejected homeowners blame the lenders, the lenders blame their computers or the government - meanwhile, the housing market continues its slow descent down the cliffside to the sea. What’s the real explanation here?
I can only tell you about my own experience, and the results of my research. But I think that I may have come upon the clearest explanation of the problem yet.
We aren’t having any problem making our mortgage payment, but we are in the third year of a 10 year interest only loan, and it’s always been my goal to refinance into a 30 year fixed rate plan before the reset date. The collapse of the real estate market hasn’t really changed my plans, since our reset date is still far off enough in the future that there is a real chance of an equity-building recovery before then. But does concern me, though, is the credit crunch, which is now requiring homeowners to have near-perfect FICO scores and at least 20% equity to qualify for a mortgage. Right now, we’re in negative equity territory, but not by too much - it looks like our home value is only down by about 5%, but I don’t see our equity approaching 20% anytime soon. My FICO score is alright, but it’s nowhere near perfect. The lenders want supermodel-hot FICO scores, and mine would only qualify as “girl-next-door” attractive.
So, when the Making Home Affordable plan was announced, it seemed like a wonderful opportunity to convert to a fixed rate mortgage much sooner than planned, and with no inquiry into either income or FICO score. I went through the qualification questions on the government’s website, and I seemed to qualify on all counts - home is a principal residence, it’s backed by Fannie Mae, all of that. So, I called Countrywide. In fact, I’ve called Countrywide three times and spoken with three different people.
I called the first representative in April, and after pulling up my account, said that my mortgage qualified, but could not be refinanced yet. He told me that the Making Home Affordable plan was only in “Phase 1″ and that my type of loan would probably qualify in “Phase 2″. Mind you, none of the documentation that the government has published has any mention of “phases”. He told me to call back in May.
In May, I called, got the representative’s voicemail, and instead decided to call the main Countrywide hotline. I was connected to a very nice woman, who pulled up my account, and then said to me that my mortgage did not qualify for refinance, yet. She said things may change in the future. When pressed, she only said that there was “additional insurance purchased for the loan” which made no sense to me, since we do not carry PMI. I know that a lot of websites out there have reported that the first round of refinancings are excluding mortgages with PMI, since PMI ensures that the lenders will get paid in the event of default anyway, so there’s no rush to refinance them. Makes sense to me, but as I’ve said, we don’t have PMI.
This morning, I called Countrywide again, because it was bothering me that I did not press further on the “additional insurance” issue. This conversation yielded the most fruit - the representative told me that the plan was still in Phase 1, and that Phase 2 was now scheduled to start in June. So, I gained some degree of satisfaction knowing that I was still being rejected under the same Phase 1 rules that blocked me in April. He told me that my mortgage may have been lumped in, or securitized, with some subprime loans which made me ineligible for a Phase 1 refinance. Then he told me that the reason for the sluggishness in the execution of the plan was a lack of guidance from the Treasury Department. He told me that customers are blaming the lenders for not refinancing them, but the lenders cannot proceed with the refinancing until clearer instructions are received from the government. His argument carries some weight, and here’s why.
I did some Googling on “Phase 1″, “Making Home Affordable”, and “Countrywide”, and a number of people are being told the same thing, more or less. But of particular note is this column from Bankrate.com, which explains that, even if you don’t carry PMI, your mortgage may have been subject to mortgage pool insurance, where a lender buys additional insurance against a securitized pool of mortgages. The article states:
Individual mortgage insurance is like auto insurance, where each policy covers one particular vehicle. Pool coverage is sort of like group medical coverage, in which the employer buys one policy that covers a group of employees.
And, then, here’s the kicker:
The system of securitizing mortgages, and insuring mortgages, wasn’t built to accommodate what I described in the previous two paragraphs. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and seven mortgage insurance companies have been updating software and figuring out the complex workflows that it will take to get these refinances done. It’s taking a lot of time.
They have been duct-taping the system to accommodate refinances of loans with individual mortgage insurance policies. But they haven’t figured out what to do about mortgages that have pool insurance.
So, from this, I’m concluding that it really isn’t Countrywide’s (or any other lender) fault, nor is it the government’s. It’s a big programming dilemma, and the artificial implementation of a Phase 1 and Phase 2 is just the industry’s way of stalling until an appropriate software solution is devised. The lenders, though, aren’t doing themselves any favors if they aren’t explaining this correctly to their customers.
If you’ve been subjected to the “Phase 1″ speech by your lender, try to hang in there, and don’t give up hope. And don’t let yourself be talked into going through a traditional refinance as a substitute, because that will not guarantee you the best rates and will cost you thousands in closing costs.swine flu symtoms Tamiflu For Prophylaxis Of Influenza buy tamiflu lowest cost?
flu shoots companys Otc Tamiflu swine flu
buy tamiflu without a prescription Tamiflu Used Since tamiflu antiviral stockpiling
tamiflu suspension no prescription Tamiflu Medicene tamiflu without a prescribtion
“flu medication tamiflu” Tamiflu Sales Swine flu symptoms and treatments swine flu symptoms and treatments ’swine flu’ 245.
tamiflu adverse events Flu Shoots Essex County Ny molen flu shoots
cdc + swine flu treatment Tamiflu What Abnormal Behaviour Was Exhibited swine flu in ohio
tamiflu for bird flu and 2007, Children Tylenol Flu tamiflu shelf life
tylenol flu night time; Medwatch Form For Tamiflu tamiflu and effectiveness and safety
tamiflu in dogs! Tamiflu Efficacy tamiflu for only 4 days
“ingridients of tamiflu” Pediatric Tamiflu Pyschiatric intestinal flu
“number needed to treat for tamiflu” Tamiflu 75 Mg Bulk Purchase Online medwatch form for tamiflu
Wiki tamiflu will tamiflu help reduce fever 870. I Get Tamiflu tamiflu otc!
tamiflu recalls! Tamiflu Ingredian tamiflu
tamiflu manufacturer gilliad Flu Shoot Baltimore Location swine flu mask
“panleukopenia and tamiflu” Tamiflu For Only 4 Days “rebate on tamiflu”
depo provera flu interfere? Thermisol In Tamiflu tamiflu and seizure
swine flu conspiracy, Tylenol Flu Pregnant aids tamiflu flu
tamiflu nausea Flu Valtrex tamiflu invent
prevention of flu Tamiflu Cheap Without Prescription chilli cold and flu treatment
gilead science donald rumsfeld tamiflu Tamiflu Synovitis tamiflu and parvo?
prophylactic tamiflu Tamiflu Roche Dick Cheney tamiflu roche
Swine flu death toll swine flu death victems on tamiflu 367. Tamiflu And Weight Gain tamiflu roche dick cheney
flu prevention signs Tylenol Flu Severe who invented tamiflu
rogaine flu symptoms Tylenol Flu Shot Pravachol nexium actos phentermine tamiflu prednisone and flu shots 199.
flu shot and tylenol, Tamiflu Generic stock ticker who makes tamiflu
does tamiflu work 12 Mg Tamiflu influenza a tamiflu
aids tamiflu flu Alberta Prescription Tamiflu 2009 flu multnomah county oregon
rumsfeld’s growing stake in tamiflu fort detrick Role Of Np Flu Tamiflu pediatric tamiflu
buy tamiflu Tamiflu Buy swine flu wisconsin
generic for tamiflu Flu Shoot Clinics Northwestern Pa Swine flu masks swine flu methotrexate 480.
Tamiflu uk shop tamiflu use in avian flu 546. Tamiflu From Canada tamiflu on line
tamiflu stomach flu Who Owns Tamiflu tylenol flu pregnant
flu treatments without tylenol Government Buys Tamiflu post-exposure tamiflu dosing
home treatment of the flu; Cdc Tamiflu tamiflu alcohol,
“relenza vs tamiflu” Tamiflu Nausea tamiflu hemorrhoid
Tamiflu flu tamiflu for acute influenza a 23. Que Es El Tamiflu tamiflu dosing instructions
stomach flu and treatments! Tamiflu History acheter tamiflu?
what are some treatments of swine flu Tamiflu Adverse Reactions Recent News flu symptoms prilosec
flu shoots companys Reactions To Flu Shoots swine flu
buy tamiflu without a prescription Voltarol Flu Like Symptom tamiflu antiviral stockpiling
tamiflu suspension no prescription Swine Flu Methotrexate tamiflu without a prescribtion
“flu medication tamiflu” Tamiflu Order Without A Prescription Swine flu symptoms and treatments swine flu symptoms and treatments ’swine flu’ 245.
tamiflu adverse events Pravachol Nexium Actos Phentermine Tamiflu molen flu shoots
cdc + swine flu treatment Flu Shot And Depakote swine flu in ohio
tamiflu for bird flu and 2007, Tamiflu Use In Avian Flu tamiflu shelf life
tylenol flu night time; Flu Like Symptoms From Prilosec tamiflu and effectiveness and safety
tamiflu in dogs! Number Needed To Treat For Tamiflu tamiflu for only 4 days
“ingridients of tamiflu” Nose Bleeds And Tamiflu intestinal flu
“number needed to treat for tamiflu” Flu Symptoms Prilosec medwatch form for tamiflu
Wiki tamiflu will tamiflu help reduce fever 870. Tamiflu Maker tamiflu otc!
tamiflu recalls! Actos Flu Symptoms None S Objection tamiflu
tamiflu manufacturer gilliad Tamiflu Singapore Stockpile swine flu mask
“panleukopenia and tamiflu” Publics Florida Flu Shoots “rebate on tamiflu”
depo provera flu interfere? Kop Tamiflu tamiflu and seizure
swine flu conspiracy, Complete Entire Treatment Of Tamiflu aids tamiflu flu
tamiflu nausea Tamiflu For Children tamiflu invent
prevention of flu Where Can You Buy Tamiflu chilli cold and flu treatment
gilead science donald rumsfeld tamiflu Panleukopenia And Tamiflu tamiflu and parvo?
prophylactic tamiflu Tamiflu And Cystic Fibrosis tamiflu roche
Swine flu death toll swine flu death victems on tamiflu 367. Tamiflu Sale tamiflu roche dick cheney
flu prevention signs Tamiflu For Swine who invented tamiflu
rogaine flu symptoms Motrin Cold And Flu Pravachol nexium actos phentermine tamiflu prednisone and flu shots 199.
flu shot and tylenol, Bird Flu Tamiflu stock ticker who makes tamiflu



